The Witchery by the Castle

Fabulous venue amazing service and delicious food Highly recommended !

Disappointing - the location history and building are great - the food was very disappointing - very bland and drastically overpriced for what was put on the plates - this was not a fine dining experience sorry

Great food, great service!

Excellent food and service. Great atmosphere

Fabulous dining experience on every level

Went here for special birthday celebration. Booking online was extremely easy. We were seated in the Secret Garden room which is our favourite of the two dining areas. Absolutely brilliant and attentive service. Excellent food and drinks. A real treat

Excellent food. Exceptional location and decor. Very attentive staff.

Fabulous room, wonderful atmosphere and great food. Thank you also for the lovely attentive service

Beautiful surroundings, professional and courteous staff, very disappointing food

Scallops were exquisite

The experience was fantastic. We had been to Michelin starred restaurant the day before but the food, service and experience was far superior here. We were made to feel very welcome, and the staff and chef were very accommodating to our requests. The food was divine, and the sommelier was knowledgeable and friendly too. Would thoroughly recommend this place.

Everything was just perfect at the witchery. Service was first class and food was gorgeous. Well worth it

I enjoyed a fabulous birthday at this restaurant. The location, the ambience, the food and the service were all excellent. The Haggis starter was super and I shared the Lamb Wellington which was absolutely delicious! My husband pre-arranged some surprises for my birthday and they were all dealt with without any problems. All these factors contributed to making the evening a very special occasion and we will certainly be visiting again.

Good meal, very good Haggis, good service from nice staff.

Great locations and ambiance. Everything else, fair.

great place. Nice staff Wine overpriced and food mediocre. Very disappointed

Wonderful service, lovely setting and delicious food. Ideal for a romantic dinner during a weekend away in Edinburgh.

Steeped in history and located just by the castle this restaurant has a beautiful secret garden for intimate dining. Venison was delicious.

We returned after10 years and were very disappointed. There was no atmosphere or anything relating to the theme or name this time. The meals were small and grossly overpriced. There are far better places to eat in Edinburgh now and we will not return. We felt as if we’d been “fleeced.” Obviously it is now a place for one off tourist visits.

Overpriced and left feeling ripped off. £10 for single measure of gin is disgusting.